gramvoy
English · B2 · Modal verbs

Should Have, Could Have, Would Have

Regrets, criticism and missed chances in the past. Read the rule, then practise with 30 sentences — and an explanation after every answer.

30 exercises≈ 10 minPDF with answer keyNo sign-up
The rule

Should have, could have and would have look back at the past, usually at something that did not happen. Should have says it was the right thing to do — a regret or a criticism: I should have saved more (I didn’t). Shouldn’t have says something did happen, and it was a mistake: You shouldn’t have paid for me. Could have says something was possible — an option nobody took, or a danger that luckily passed: We could have flown, but we went by train; You could have been killed! Would have imagines the result of a different past: She would have enjoyed the concert (but she wasn’t there).

The form is the same for every person: modal + have + past participle (the third form) — should have gone, could have written, would have eaten. It is always have, not has or had, and never the past simple: should have went. Negatives are shouldn’t have, couldn’t have and wouldn’t have; questions put the modal first: Should I have called? In speech have shrinks to ’ve — should’ve, could’ve, would’ve — and sounds like of. That is why people write should of, but in writing it is always have.

Choose by meaning. Was it the right or the wrong thing — it was a mistake, I feel terrible, now I regret it? Use should have or shouldn’t have. Was it simply possible — but we chose…, That was dangerous!, so easy that…? Use could have; couldn’t have says it was impossible: We couldn’t have climbed it without ropes. Is it the result of something that didn’t happen — but…, otherwise, an if-clause? Use would have. It is the second half of the third conditional: If she had asked, I would have helped — the if-clause itself takes had + participle.

Two neighbours look similar. Must have and can’t have are built the same way, but they are deductions about what you are almost sure did or didn’t happen: The lights are off — they must have gone out (I’m sure they did). And in criticism should have and could have can be close: You should have warned me! / You could have warned me! — could have points out that it was possible. For a danger that passed, might have works too: You might have been hurt. And like might have, could have can be a guess about the past: He could have left already (maybe he did). The exercises below never make you choose between two of these that both fit.

Quick reference

What each one means

should = right · could = possible · would = result
should have: the right thing didn’t happenI should have saved more money when I was younger.
shouldn’t have: it happened, but it was a mistakeWe shouldn’t have stayed up so late — I’m exhausted.
could have: possible, but it didn’t happenThey could have sold the house, but they decided to keep it.
could have: a danger that passedSlow down! You could have hit that cyclist.
couldn’t have: it was impossibleWe couldn’t have won without our goalkeeper.
would have: an imagined resultShe would have enjoyed the trip, but she had to work.

Form and look-alikes

modal + have + third form
The same form for every personI / she / they should have asked
Negativesshouldn’t have · couldn’t have · wouldn’t have + past participle
QuestionsShould we have waited? · What would you have done?
Speech: ’ve, not ofshould’ve = should have — should of is a spelling mistake
Link to the third conditionalIf she had taken the job, she would have moved to Rome.
Deduction looks the sameThe lights are off — they must have gone out. (I’m sure they did.)

Common mistakes

have, never has or of — then the third form
  • She should have wrote to them.She should have written to them.(past participle)
  • You should of asked me.You should have asked me.(’ve, not of)
  • He should has called.He should have called.(have for every person)
  • You shouldn’t said that.You shouldn’t have said that.(the past needs have)
  • They would stayed longer, but it rained.They would have stayed longer, but it rained.
  • We should book a table last week.We should have booked a table last week.(past, not advice)

Printable worksheet, A4 and Letter

The same 30 exercises on two pages, with an answer key and short explanations on the last page. Free for classroom use — no sign-up.

Download PDF ↓
Practice

Answer first, then read why.

Pick an option and the sentence is corrected in place, with a short explanation underneath. Keys a–d answer the next exercise.

Exercise 01 of 300 correct · 0 to revisit
Exercise 01 of 30Tag: should have done

It’s raining and I’m soaking wet. I blank an umbrella.

Exercise 02 of 30Tag: should have done

I couldn’t sleep at all. I blank so much coffee last night.

Exercise 03 of 30Tag: should have done

We blank a taxi, but it was a lovely evening, so we walked.

Exercise 04 of 30Tag: had / have + 3rd form

I blank you to the airport, but my car had broken down.

Exercise 05 of 30Tag: 've, not of

You blank me you were coming! I’d have made dinner.

Exercise 06 of 30Tag: 've, not of

It’s a pity you missed the party. You blank it.

Exercise 07 of 30Tag: should have done

That was close! You blank yourself with that knife.

Exercise 08 of 30Tag: couldn't have

Thanks so much for your help. I blank it without you.

Exercise 09 of 30Tag: should have done

blank I blank a tie? All the other guests are wearing one.

Exercise 10 of 30Tag: should have done

I blank to the party if I’d known Max would be there.

Exercise 11 of 30Tag: shouldn't have

You blank so rude to her yesterday. She was only trying to help.

Exercise 12 of 30Tag: should have: regret

I forgot my sister’s birthday. I blank a reminder on my phone last week.

Exercise 13 of 30Tag: shouldn't have

I ate three pieces of cake, and now I feel sick. I blank so many.

Exercise 14 of 30Tag: could have: possible

Never climb onto the roof again! You blank off and broken your leg.

Exercise 15 of 30Tag: would have: result

I blank you last night, but my phone battery was dead.

Exercise 16 of 30Tag: would have: result

Luckily, I checked the date on my ticket. Otherwise I blank at the airport a day late.

Exercise 17 of 30Tag: couldn't have

I blank the conference even if I’d wanted to — I was ill all week.

Exercise 18 of 30Tag: should have: regret

The fridge is empty. We blank some food on the way home yesterday.

Exercise 19 of 30Tag: could have: possible

The exam was so easy that I blank it with my eyes closed.

Exercise 20 of 30Tag: couldn't have

The weather on our wedding day was perfect. It blank better.

Exercise 21 of 30Tag: should or could?

My parents let me decide. I blank law, but I chose music, and I’ve never regretted it.

Exercise 22 of 30Tag: should or should have?

You blank me yesterday! Next time, you blank me straight away.

Exercise 23 of 30Tag: regret or deduction?

Kate isn’t here yet. She blank the bus. She blank home earlier.

Exercise 24 of 30Tag: would have done

We blank yesterday’s match if our best player hadn’t been injured.

Exercise 25 of 30Tag: if + had done

If you blank me about the traffic, I would have left earlier.

Exercise 26 of 30Tag: find the mistake
Choose the correct sentence

Which sentence is correct?

Exercise 27 of 30Tag: find the mistake
Choose the correct sentence

Which sentence is correct?

Exercise 28 of 30Tag: find the mistake
Choose the correct sentence

Which sentence is correct?

Exercise 29 of 30Tag: find the mistake
Choose the correct sentence

Which sentence is correct?

Exercise 30 of 30Tag: find the mistake
Choose the correct sentence

Which sentence is correct?

Common questions

Should Have, Could Have, Would Have: common questions

What is the difference between should have, could have and would have?

Should have says what was the right thing to do but didn’t happen: I should have checked. Could have says what was possible but didn’t happen: We could have walked. Would have gives the result of a different past: She would have enjoyed it.

Is it “should of” or “should have”?

It is always should have in writing. In fast speech should’ve sounds like “should of”, which is why people write it, but of is not a verb. The same goes for could of and would of.

Can I say “You could have warned me!”?

Yes. You could have warned me and You should have warned me both criticise someone for not doing something. Could have points out that it was possible; should have says it was the right thing to do.

What does “shouldn’t have” mean?

It criticises something that did happen: You shouldn’t have driven so fast means you drove fast, and it was a mistake. As a thank-you for a present, Oh, you shouldn’t have! means it wasn’t necessary.

How is “would have” connected to the third conditional?

Would have + past participle is the result half of the third conditional: If we had left earlier, we would have caught the train. Often the if-part is only implied or replaced by but: She would have helped, but nobody asked her.

What is the difference between “should have” and “must have”?

Should have done is about something that didn’t happen, and it is a regret or criticism: He should have written it down. Must have done is a deduction — you are almost sure it did happen: He must have forgotten.