gramvoy
English · B2 · Modal verbs

Modals of Deduction

Must, might or can’t: how sure are you? Read the rule, then practise with 30 sentences — and an explanation after every answer.

30 exercises≈ 10 minPDF with answer keyNo sign-up
The rule

Modals of deduction show how sure you are about something, based on what you can see or know. Must means you are almost certain it is true, can’t means you are almost certain it is not true, and might, may and could mean it is possible. They have one form for every person and take the base form without to: she must be busy, it can’t be far, they might know, never she musts be or must to be. For an action in progress now, use be + -ing: He must be sleeping.

For the past, add have + past participle: They must have left, She can’t have seen it, I might have forgotten. Couldn’t have works like can’t have: He couldn’t have known. The time in the sentence decides the form: now, at the moment → must be; yesterday, last night → must have been.

The evidence decides the modal. Strong evidence for → must: She’s been running for an hour — she must be exhausted. Strong evidence against → can’t: He can’t be at work — his office is closed today. No real evidence, or I’m not sure, maybe → might, may or could. For “possibly not”, use might not or may not; couldn’t means the same as can’t. Positive can is not used for a guess about one situation: It might rain later, not It can rain later. And don’t mix up must have done (I’m sure it happened) with had to do (it was necessary).

Mustn’t in British English usually means “not allowed”, so for a negative deduction British speakers say can’t. In American English must not is also common here: He must not be home. The exercises below use can’t and never make you choose between the two, so every answer is correct in both British and American English.

Quick reference

How sure are you?

must = sure yes · can’t = sure no · might = maybe
must: almost certain it is trueHer coat isn’t here, so she must be on her way.
can’t: almost certain it is not trueThat can’t be our train — it’s going the wrong way.
might / may / could: possibleTake an umbrella — it might rain this afternoon.
might not / may not: possibly notHe may not remember my name — we only met once.
In progress now: be + -ingThe line is busy, so he must be talking to someone.

Deductions about the past

modal + have + past participle
must have + participleThe road is wet — it must have rained in the night.
can’t have / couldn’t have + participleShe can’t have heard me — she had headphones on.
might have / may have / could have + participleI might have put the tickets in my other bag.
In progress then: have been + -ingYou were very quiet — you must have been thinking about work.
Deduction or obligation?He must have missed the train (I’m sure) · he had to take a taxi (it was necessary)

Common mistakes

no to, no -s, have + third form
  • She musts be tired.She must be tired.(one form for every person)
  • He must to be at work.He must be at work.(no to)
  • It can rain later.It might rain later.(a possible situation)
  • We must have forgot her birthday.We must have forgotten her birthday.(past participle)
  • He must left early.He must have left early.(the past needs have)
  • Maybe she must be ill.She might be ill.(not sure = might)

Printable worksheet, A4 and Letter

The same 30 exercises on two pages, with an answer key and short explanations on the last page. Free for classroom use — no sign-up.

Download PDF ↓
Practice

Answer first, then read why.

Pick an option and the sentence is corrected in place, with a short explanation underneath. Keys a–d answer the next exercise.

Exercise 01 of 300 correct · 0 to revisit
Exercise 01 of 30Tag: must be, might be

Anna has been travelling all day. She blank tired.

Exercise 02 of 30Tag: must be, might be

Where’s Ben? I’m not sure — he blank in the library.

Exercise 03 of 30Tag: might, may, could

Nobody is answering the phone at the office. They blank in a meeting.

Exercise 04 of 30Tag: must be, might be

That man blank her father — he looks the same age as her.

Exercise 05 of 30Tag: must be doing

The music upstairs is very loud. The neighbours blank a party.

Exercise 06 of 30Tag: must be doing

Don’t call Tom now — he blank for his exam.

Exercise 07 of 30Tag: must have done

Kate looks very happy. She blank her driving test.

Exercise 08 of 30Tag: must have done

Leo blank my message — he hasn’t been online since Friday.

Exercise 09 of 30Tag: must have done

I can’t find my glasses. I blank them at the café.

Exercise 10 of 30Tag: might, may, could

Tell Maria about the change of plan — she blank yet.

Exercise 11 of 30Tag: must: almost sure

The lights are off and nobody is answering the door. I’m sure they blank out.

Exercise 12 of 30Tag: might, may, could

I’m not sure where Lucy is. She blank at the gym, or maybe at work.

Exercise 13 of 30Tag: can't: impossible

Mark blank hungry — he’s just eaten a huge pizza.

Exercise 14 of 30Tag: must: almost sure

Your phone hasn’t stopped ringing. Somebody blank to talk to you urgently.

Exercise 15 of 30Tag: might, may, could

Jack is late again. He blank his bus, or maybe he overslept.

Exercise 16 of 30Tag: can't: impossible

You blank my sister at the party — she was in Paris that weekend.

Exercise 17 of 30Tag: must: almost sure

The front door is open and my laptop is gone. Someone blank in!

Exercise 18 of 30Tag: must: almost sure

Sam has worked in this small office for thirty years. He blank everyone here.

Exercise 19 of 30Tag: can't: impossible

The window was locked from the inside, so the thief blank in that way.

Exercise 20 of 30Tag: might, may, could

Don’t throw that box away — it blank useful one day.

Exercise 21 of 30Tag: now or the past?

Emma’s light was still on at 2 a.m. She blank late last night.

Exercise 22 of 30Tag: now or the past?

Paul keeps yawning. He blank tired — he blank much last night.

Exercise 23 of 30Tag: guess or obligation?

I blank my keys somewhere, so I blank wait outside for an hour.

Exercise 24 of 30Tag: now or the past?

Nina didn’t hear the doorbell last night. She blank to music.

Exercise 25 of 30Tag: now or the past?

“Is that Anna’s bike?” “It blank hers — she sold her bike last month.”

Exercise 26 of 30Tag: find the mistake
Choose the correct sentence

Which sentence is correct?

Exercise 27 of 30Tag: find the mistake
Choose the correct sentence

Which sentence is correct?

Exercise 28 of 30Tag: find the mistake
Choose the correct sentence

Which sentence is correct?

Exercise 29 of 30Tag: find the mistake
Choose the correct sentence

Which sentence is correct?

Exercise 30 of 30Tag: find the mistake
Choose the correct sentence

Which sentence is correct?

Common questions

Modals of Deduction: common questions

What are modals of deduction?

They are modal verbs that show how sure you are, based on evidence: must (almost certainly true), can’t (almost certainly not true) and might, may, could (possible). The bus is late — there must be a lot of traffic.

What is the difference between must, might and can’t?

It is the degree of certainty. She must be at home — I’m almost sure she is. She might be at home — perhaps. She can’t be at home — I’m almost sure she isn’t.

How do we make deductions about the past?

Use the modal + have + past participle: must have gone, might have forgotten, can’t have seen, couldn’t have known. For an action in progress, use have been + -ing: He must have been sleeping.

Why is it can’t and not mustn’t for a negative deduction?

In British English mustn’t usually means “not allowed”, so a negative deduction takes can’t: That can’t be right. In American English must not is also used for deduction: He must not be home.

Is there a difference between might, may and could?

For a possibility they mean almost the same: She might / may / could be ill. In the negative they split: might not and may not mean “possibly not”, while couldn’t means “impossible”, like can’t.

Is “must have done” the same as “had to do”?

No. She must have left is a deduction — I’m sure she left. She had to leave is an obligation — it was necessary for her to leave.